Hi Ken: The reason behind such definitions is of a practical nature. There must be at least 3,000 species of geophytes (and perhaps 50,000 named hybrids in cultivation?) to portrait and discuss. There has to be a limit to such an amount of work. Then it sounds sensible that those that are not geophytes are not included. Interestingly in many areas of South America that are dryish and hot very many plants look "bulbous" but they aren't. It is an adaptation to periodical fires and most (if not all) are woody and carrot like. In other words, a tree or shrub of small size completely buried in the ground and from which only the soft green parts emerge. This organs are xylopodiums but not bulbs, corms and tubers. More like caudiciforms. Regards Alberto _________________________________________________________________ MSN Amor: busca tu ½ naranja http://latam.msn.com/amor/