Thank u for the answers so far. Mary Sue sent me the What's a Bulb link, from our wiki & I was surprised to notice salvia & grass trees included. Very interesting & we do have a grass after all :) Well after having a read of the wiki & looking at this from a plant vrs bulb thought.. It seems to me in regard to plants that don't really fit the description or criteria of a bulb or geophyte, perhaps we should have them all in a fleshy rooted plants section. I haven't looked yet, if they are.. Then we still accommodate people like Travis who have mad the wonderful effort to add to the wiki, but with boarder line plants. Just an idea ! I must agree with Alberto & Roger, It seems to me as a bulb collector, if we add very boarder line plants that aren't normally considered to be grown for their bulbs or tuberous qualities, especially when they have a normal plant like growth habit instead of even looking like a bulb or lily, we run the risk of appearing to have a Plant and Bulbs Wiki, & we could loose the exclusive ability to contribute an exclusive bulb wiki to the world... "That's only my opinion though" On 21 February 2015 at 04:54, Alberto <ezeizabotgard@hotmail.com> wrote: > To me it is is good news and no doubt Mary Sue Ittner who is a monumental > bulb grower has clear ideas of what is bulb and what is not. IBS was > exclusive, based on other grounds and PBS is the number one bulb site in > the world. But, the info we provide must be accurate. I am always thinking > in the newbie (as we all were many years ago) seeking for precise data on > an otherwise ocean like subject. We can not teach the bulb cultivation of > plants that never bear any bulbs (Bulbinella, Zingiber, Kniphofia, all > Lewisias but one species, etc., etc.) > > > > _______________________________________________ > pbs mailing list > pbs@lists.ibiblio.org > http://pacificbulbsociety.org/list.php > http://pacificbulbsociety.org/pbswiki/ > -- Steven : ) Esk Queensland Australia Summer Zone 5 Winter Zone 10