Thanks to Mary Sue Ittner for her well-composed and thoughtful response to this discussion. I fully agree that there is no harm in allowing members to add genera or species that are marginally geophytic to the wiki. Those who are not interested in these genera need not look at those entries. It should simply be made clear in the introduction to the page what type of underground storage structure is present. The internet is a library, not an exercise in scientific classification. If searching for Paeonia (or even Cynoglossum) leads someone to the PBS, we should simply appreciate that opportunity. Jane McGary Portland, Oregon, USA