Colchicum cilicicum blooming and more on new blog post
Jane McGary (Tue, 06 Oct 2015 18:51:55 PDT)
Kathy wrote,
What I would really like to know is,
what source is considered authoritative for identifying colchicums? When I
first became interested in them, I was told that Crocus & Colchicum by E.A.
Bowles (what I believe Jim is referring to as Bowles' handbook) was the
definitive authority. Is that still the case? Just recently (9/21) Jim
referred to the colchicaceae.e-monocot.org website, and Travis referenced
the European Garden Flora. Today both Jim and Travis referred to the Plant
List. Are any (or all) of these considered more authoritative than Bowles?
Bowles, /Crocus and Colchicum/, is now regarded as problematic and is
not recommended as an authority. The Kew Plantlist is widely used as an
authority at present. However, for Colchicum, Karen Persson has prepared
but not yet published what is intended to be a definitive monograph. It
names many species that may not be present in other lists. /Flora Europa
/has, I think, not been updated for some years.
The upshot of all this is, I think, that if we are distributing
Colchicum species or cultivars, we should just do so under the names
under which we received them, with an appropriate caveat and as much
source data as we have. When I used to sell bulbs, I resorted to this in
the case of Narcissus species, in which there are many controversial names.
Jim remarked that his stock under the name 'Lilac Wonder' does not show
tessellation ("chequering"). Neither does mine. If it were a hybrid with
C. bivonae, I would expect tessellation. Many of the old hybrids with
large, tessellated flowers are hybrids between C. bivonae and C.
speciosum, mostly produced early in the 20th century. Another
large-flowered species producing tessellation is C. variegatum, one of
the parents of the cultivars grown under the name C. x agrippinum.
However, C. variegatum is thought not to be very cold-hardy (mine have
survived 18 degrees F while fairly dry).
Jane McGary
Portland, Oregon, USA